ISSN-0972-9445
Emerging Trends in Development Research
Vol. 32, No. 1 & 2, 2025, 71-130
(Re)Conversion Matters
Susheel Kumar Sharma
Professor of English, Department of English & Modern European Languages
University of Allahabad, Prayagraj – 211002, INDIA
Email: <sksharma@allduniv.ac.in>, ORCid: 0000-0002-2220-072X
Abstract
This paper establishes religious conversion in India as a complex socio-political act rather than a purely theological decision. It examines the conversion in India as a critical barometer of the tension between constitutional secularism and socio-religious realities. The author contends that conversion functions as a critical determinant of national narrative and socio-political power. The core argument posits a fundamental conflict between the “open-source,” non-creedal framework of Sanatana Dharma and the exclusive, proselytizing mandates of Abrahamic faiths. The author argues that while Hinduism emphasizes orthopraxy and lacks a formal concept of apostasy, the rigid entry-exit requirements of Christianity and Islam are often perceived as a “cultural invasion” that threatens indigenous identity and demographic stability. The paper also analyses how Hindus feel dented in their encounters with Abrahamic faiths over the centuries.
Furthermore, the paper investigates the historical evolution of “homecoming” movements, tracing the methodological shift from Adi Shankara’s intellectual Shastrartha to the Arya Samaj’s reformist Shuddhi and the contemporary Ghar Wapsi initiatives, and establishes a historical continuity between medieval resistance to forced conversion and modern reclamation movements like Shuddhi and Ghar Wapsi. It evaluates the legal landscape, specifically Article 25 of the Indian Constitution, which distinguishes the right to “propagate” from the right to “convert”. Finally, the study addresses the socio-political implications of conversion, including demographic anxieties and the “Good Cop, Bad Cop” dynamic between the BJP and VHP regarding institutional distancing from aggressive reconversion tactics. Ultimately, the paper contends that conversion is not merely a personal change of faith but a profound socio-political negotiation of power and national narrative in post-colonial India.
Keywords: Anti-Conversion Laws, Apostasy, Article 25, Ghar Wapsi, Hindu Nationalism, Indian Secularism, Religious Conversion, Proselytization, Sanatana Dharma, Socio-political Power.
